Faith opened the door awkwardly, then dumped the case of beer on the counter.
She closed the door behind her, and set the bags of food next to the beer.
"Since we're staying in tonight," she grinned. "I thought a little game might be appropriate."
Dean & Sam
"Does it involve you naked?" Dean quipped, before quickly following it with an apology to Sam.
"What kind of game?" Sam asked.
Faith
Faith opened the case of beer and handed one to Dean, then one to Sam. She took one for herself and went to sit on the bed.
"Never have I ever."
Sam
"Which is...?" Sam shook his head, opening his bottle.
Faith
Making sure Sam was watching, Faith grinned cheekily and opened her beer bottle using her belly button.
"Ok, well... someone says a statement... like... 'never have I ever... kissed a girl'. And if you have done it, you drink."
Dean & Sam
"Sounds fun," Dean grinned, "but shouldn't we be doing it with something like straight vodka?"
"Oh God no," Sam scorned.
Faith
Faith grinned.
"Nah, because poor Sam would be dead. And I quite like him coherent."
Dean & Sam
"Oh I'm sure he'll be sober hours into this," Dean smirked.
"Oh yeah?" Sam's eyebrows rose, "why don't we find out?"
Dean indicated for Faith to start.
Faith
"Never have I ever... been with two girls at once," Faith said.
She grinned slightly, and took a sip.
Dean & Sam
"See?" Dean smirked triumphantly, taking a swig.
Sam just rolled his eyes.
Faith
Faith laughed.
"Someone else go."
Dean & Sam
"Never have I ever..." Dean began thoughtfully.
"Done it with twins."
He drank, and Sam huffed a little.
Faith
Faith grinned and took a swig.
"Never have I ever..." she wiggled her eyebrows evilly. "Kissed a guy."
Dean & Sam
"Do brothers count?" Dean raised an eyebrow.
"Dude, when was the last time you kissed me?" Sam looked disturbed.
"I don't know," Dean paused thoughtfully, "third grade?"
"I don't think she means that kind of kiss," Sam assured.
"Then I'm out," Dean shook his head.
"In that case," Sam went to drink.
"What?!" Dean's eyes widened.
Sam broke out laughing.
"I'm kidding," he pulled the bottle from his lips, "but at this rate I won't get any anyway. I'll have to make stuff up."
Faith
Faith grinned, then leant over to kiss Sam.
"Awww."
Sam & Dean
"Gee thanks," Sam smirked.
"Never have I ever slept with someone while pretending to be a fed," Dean announced.
"Oh! Got one!" Sam happily took a drink as his brother did.
Faith
Faith grinned at Sam.
"Oh, you're so cute when you're excited."
Sam & Dean
"Shut up," Sam blushed a little.
"Never have I ever... gone skinny dipping?"
Dean thought it over.
"I've been told I have, but I was too drunk to remember it," he shrugged, before drinking.
Faith
Faith took a sip, then leaned back.
"Never have I ever... thought about having hot, filthy sex with someone in this room."
Sam & Dean
"Me again!" Sam fist pumped before both he and Dean drank again.
Faith
Faith swallowed the mouthful of beer she had, then leaned over to kiss Sam.
"I think I like you this way."
Dean & Sam
"And he's not even drunk," Dean raised an eyebrow.
"Yet. Here's one: Never have I ever dug a bullet out of my own body."
"Me again," Sam drank in sync with Dean once again.
Faith
"Ditto."
Faith took a sip.
"Never have I ever... killed an innocent."
Sam & Dean
Sam's face fell a little, before both boys drank again.
"Comes with the job," Dean shrugged.
"Never have I ever stolen from the rich."
Both boys drank again.
Faith
"Well, I prefer to think of it as borrowing, but potato, potatoe," Faith shrugged, before taking a swig.
"Never have I ever... been tied up for fun."
Sam & Dean
Sam's face flushed red again as Dean smirked and drank. He waited a second, then drank also.
Dean spat half his mouthful onto the carpet.
"Sam?!"
"Shut up!" Sam pointed at him without looking.
"What have you done to my brother?" Dean asked Faith mock-seriously.
Faith
"Nothing that he didn't enjoy, trust me."
Faith grinned slightly.
Dean & Sam
Dean rolled his eyes and Sam cleared his throat.
"Never have I ever seen my life flash before my eyes."
He and Dean both drank again.
Faith
Faith drank from her bottle.
"Never have I ever... fallen in love."
Sam & Dean
Sam drank as Dean hesitated.
He thought a few things over, then drank as well.
"Why did you stop?" Sam asked him.
"I forgot," Dean shrugged.
"You forgot falling in love?" Sam's eyebrows rose.
"It was a long time ago," Dean defended.
"Never have I ever mowed a lawn."
Dean drank.
"What?" Sam looked confused.
Faith
Faith rolled the bottle between her fingertips.
"Never have I ever... held down an honest job."
The bottle remained between her fingers.
Dean & Sam
The brothers looked at each other.
"Honest as in... no credit card scams?" Sam raised his eyebrows.
Dean snorted and didn't move his bottle.
"I had a couple of side gigs in college, but they didn't pay. So I'm out," Sam shrugged.
"Never have I ever eaten something alive," Dean mused.
"Wall, girls are alive, so..."
He drank.
Sam hesitated, then drank as well.
Faith
Faith grinned, and took a long pull from her bottle.
"Girls are indeed alive."
Sam & Dean
"Never have I ever been locked out of a car in the rain," Sam drank.
Dean thought about that.
"I can't remember if I have, so I mustn't have," he shook his head.
Faith
"Never have I ever... not worn underwear in public."
Faith winked at Sam, and took a long sip.
Sam & Dean
Sam smirked as Dean drank with her.
"You're kidding," Dean coughed when he finished.
"What?" Sam shrugged innocently.
"You've never gone commando?"
"I have no reason to, we have plenty of underwear," Sam reasoned.
"Whatever. Never have I ever done drunk karaoke."
Sam pulled a face and drank.
Faith
Faith grinned.
"That was a great night."
Sam & Dean
"While I was conscious, anyway," Sam rolled his eyes.
"Never have I ever had dirty thoughts about something I ended up killing."
Dean gave him a scornful look.
"What?" Sam shrugged.
Dean continued staring, before drinking.
Faith
Faith thought about that for a second, then took a sip.
"Never have I ever kicked someone out right after sex."
She took another drink.
Dean & Sam
Dean drank.
"Really?" Sam looked surprised, "I figured she'd be kicking you out."
"Can't kick me out of my own car," Dean pointed out, "besides, she was feral."
Faith
"Never have I ever taken someone's v plates," Faith grinned.
She took a long pull from the bottle, then reached over to get a new one.
Dean & Sam
Dean finished his off as Sam drank more. Dean threw the bottle aside before pulling out another one and opening it.
"I like this game," he mused.
Faith
Faith laughed.
"Never have I ever... taped myself flying solo to send to someone."
She took another swig.
Dean & Sam
"What?!" both boys laughed incredulously.
"Do you still have the video?" Dean quickly added.
"Dean," Sam scorned.
"What?"
Faith
Faith grinned.
"I don't know if I should be shocked that you were surprised at that," she said.
And just to push it a little further, she added, "Never have I ever... allowed someone to film me putting on a personal strip show."
Sam & Dean
Sam looked at Dean who quite obviously scratched his head and looked away on purpose.
Faith
Faith whistled slightly.
"Never have I ever... trusted someone who wasn't family completely."
Dean & Sam
"Pamela?" Dean suggested to Sam.
"Works," Sam shrugged, and they both drank.
Faith
"Never have I ever... led someone on just to see them squirm."
Faith took a drink from her bottle.
Dean & Sam
"I only lead on if it's gonna end in sex," Dean nodded.
Sam hesitated.
"No, don't think so," he finally decided, "I would say you, but it doesn't work, so..."
Faith
Faith grinned slightly.
"It does work, sort of."
Sam
"Ok then," Sam shrugged, and drank.
Faith
Faith leaned over to kiss Sam again.
"Never have I ever... had sex in public."
Dean & Sam
"Oh yeah!" Dean fist pumped and chugged half the bottle.
Sam rolled his eyes and took a quick sip.
Faith
Faith laughed and then raised an eyebrow at Sam.
"Who with?"
Sam & Dean
"Nevermind," Sam insisted.
"Never have I ever been walked in on," Dean interjected, before drinking more.
Sam threw his hands up and drank.
Faith
Faith took a long swig.
"Never have I ever... cheated on someone."
Sam & Dean
Sam fiddled with the bottle as he watched Dean drink.
"But it wasn't really cheating, only the girls saw it that way," Dean defended when he was done.
Faith
"Never have I ever... been cheated on."
Faith finished the rest of her bottle.
Dean & Sam
Dean hesitated thoughtfully, then shook his head.
"Wouldn't count," he shrugged.
"Don't think I have either," Sam agreed.
Faith
"Mmm, lucky me then."
Faith nodded.
Sam & Dean
"If you've been with more people you're bound to have more of a variety of relationships," Sam shrugged.
"If she's been with more," Dean said pointedly.
Faith
"Well, only Zac cheated on me," Faith shrugged.
"Which is still confusing, because, well... I am pretty awesome."
Dean & Sam
"Amen," Dean clapped.
"Don't need to tell me," Sam shrugged, smiling cheekily.
Faith
Faith turned and straddled Sam's lap, grinning.
"Well, good to know you're not going to go jumping into bed with someone else."
Sam & Dean
"Why on Earth would I need to?" Sam mused, kissing her cheek.
"Never have I ever had to watch my brother sex up his girlfriend who used to be my sex partner for hours on end," Dean finished off his second bottle.
Faith
Faith laughed, and turned slightly to look at Dean.
"Never have I ever... thought about someone else while having sex with someone different."
Dean & Sam
Dean hesitated, then drank. Sam sighed and also drank a little.
Faith
Faith poked Sam in the chest.
"If you have been thinking of someone else while you were with me, I'll punish you."
Sam
"As much as I would like to be punished by you, it wasn't," Sam amended.
Faith
Faith smiled and kissed him on the tip of his nose.
"Good."
Dean & Sam
"Never have I ever felt so sickeningly ashamed of my brother's mushiness," Dean skulled half the next bottle.
Sam rolled his eyes.
Faith
Faith grinned.
"Would you rather he batted me around a little?"
Dean
"I'd prefer distance," Dean indicated for the two of them to move apart.
Faith
Faith hesitated, before making a move to get off Sam's lap.
"But he's so comfortable."
Dean & Sam
"Tough," Dean insisted.
Sam let Faith slide off and sat back onto the bed, taking his carton with him.
Faith
"Never have I ever... been completely fulfilled sexually with a partner."
Faith took a sip.
Sam & Dean
Sam raised an eyebrow.
"Wow, tough call," Dean smirked.
Sam shrugged and drank as well.
Faith
"It better be me," Faith grinned.
Sam & Dean
Sam winked at her.
"Never have I ever been arrested for something I didn't do," Dean drank.
Sam raised an eyebrow, stopping to think.
"Oh. Karen's murder," he realised, before drinking.
Faith
Faith didn't drink.
"Never have I ever... slept with someone twice my age."
She took a long pull.
Dean & Sam
Both boys didn't drink.
"Never have I ever slept with someone half my age," Sam smirked.
Dean grunted and drank.
Faith
Faith chuckled.
"Never have I ever kissed someone in the rain."
Dean & Sam
Both boys drank, Dean with a knowing smile on his face.
"Never have I ever followed that up with hardcore alleyway sex," he drank again.
Faith
Faith laughed and drank again.
"Never have I ever... been attracted to someone else other than my current lover, partner, whatever."
Sam & Dean
"Oh come on," Sam scorned, before drinking.
"Do I count?" Dean asked, confused, "seeing as I don't have one? Oh who cares."
He drank.
Faith
"Wait, wait," Faith took a sidelong glance at Sam.
"You've been attracted to someone other than me? Wounded."
She grinned.
Sam & Dean
"I've been attracted to every girl I've ever had sex with," Sam defended.
"You just top the pile."
"That's romantic," Dean rolled his eyes.
Faith
"No, no, I meant... have you been attracted to another girl while with me?"
Faith paused.
"Or a guy."
Sam
"You didn't specify that," Sam insisted.
"In that case, no."
Faith
"Awesome."
Faith grinned.
"Never have I ever... performed a sexual act for cash."
Dean & Sam
Dean cringed and closed his eyes.
"As if!" Sam laughed, not seeing Dean take a sip behind him.
Faith
Faith grinned.
"I'd pay for you, Sam. If I wasn't already getting it free of charge."
Dean & Sam
"That's gross," Dean complained, "next?"
"Never have I ever been sexually assaulted by someone three or four times my age," Sam chuckled, before drinking.
Dean stopped to think, coming up blank.
Faith
Faith took a long sip from her beer.
"Yeah, try... all the time."
Dean & Sam
"The staple of underground living," Dean mused.
"Never have I ever been caught between two broads I couldn't wait to get away from."
Dean drank. Sam hesitated thoughtfully, and also drank.
Faith took a sip.
"Never have I ever... had non consentual sex."
Sam & Dean
Both boys stopped to think.
"Nope," Sam shook his head, "not that I can remember anyway."
"Nothing I didn't put myself into, either," Dean shrugged, starting to wonder
when he was going to get another drink.
Faith
Faith smiled wryly, taking a sip.
"Never have I ever... had phone sex."
Dean & Sam
"Oh!" Dean looked excited for a second and drank.
Sam didn't.
Faith
"We'll have to remedy that," Faith grinned, looking at Sam.
Sam & Dean
"Hopefully we won't have to," Sam winked.
"Never have I ever spent an entire day in bed."
He drank, and Dean stopped to think.
"Oh wait, Lisa," he realised, and drank.
Faith
Faith drank and grinned after she had swallowed.
"Best 24 hours ever. Though, I could hardly walk after it."
She paused.
"Then again, I have also spent 8 months in bed."
Sam & Dean
"Now that's just cheating," Sam chuckled.
"Never have I ever committed some sort of sexual act that ended up on the
nightly news," Dean smirked.
"What?!" Sam turned to look at him.
Faith
Faith a took a sip and then high fived Dean.
"Never have I ever... guilted someone into sex."
Sam & Dean
Sam shrugged and sipped.
"I don't think I've ever had to," Dean considered, "seeing as it's usually
mutually beneficial."
Faith
Faith grinned slightly.
"Yeah, but sometimes someone isn't in the mood."
Dean & Sam
"Then I find someone else," Dean shrugged.
"Even when you were with Cassie?" Sam raised an eyebrow.
"Cassie put out," Dean defended.
Faith
"Never have I ever... made out with Sam."
Faith leaned over and kissed Sam, before taking a swig.
Dean & Sam
"That's not fair," Dean insisted.
"What?" Sam chuckled, "I can't drink either!"
"Never have I ever been so wasted that I forgot an entire weekend," Dean
began again.